WWE Payback 2014 PPV Thoughts

WWE Payback was better than it deserved to be.

The build up to this PPV (or special event as I believe they are now being called) was at best lack­lus­ter. To be fair that wasn’t entirely WWE’s fault. The situ­a­tion with Daniel Bryan and his neck surgery left them with­out a WWE Title defense and with a lot of uncer­tainty. I’ll give them credit for book­ing them­selves out of that quite well.

But even allow­ing for that, it was defi­nitely a card that felt (with the excep­tion of John Cena vs. Bray Wyatt and The Shield vs. Evolu­tion both of which were return bouts) like it was an episode of RAW.

xpay14_photo_063-1401702752.jpg.pagespeed.ic.qJvbyClzuWUS Title Match: Shea­mus vs. Cesaro

WWE defi­nitely seem to be book­ing Shea­mus as a fight­ing cham­pion which, given his consid­er­able wrestling abil­i­ties is a very good thing. Cesaro is hot right now and of course Paul Heyman as manager (or advo­cate or what­ever) adds a certain verbal spice to things.

This match defi­nitely got things off to a hot start. The two meshed well and it was fun to watch. The ending certainly leaves it open for Cesaro to come look­ing for some sort of revenge or rematch. Although it’s possi­ble that Cesaro is about to move upwards and if so he came out of this look­ing strong despite the loss.

Can I just say I love the way that Heyman actu­ally coaches Cesaro while at ring­side.

Rybaxel vs. The Broth­er­hood

After that strong start we defi­nitely swerved back into RAW terri­tory with a perfectly good but unex­cep­tional match with broth­ers Codey Rhodes and Goldust taking on the hideously named team of Ryback and Curtis Axel. Really… horri­ble name.

This was straight up a contin­u­a­tion of a slow burn­ing story that’s been going on for a month or two and it’s fine for what it is, but since the payoff here was Rhodes saying Goldust needed a better tag team part­ner it really felt like it belonged on RAW or Smack­down.

Rusev vs. Big E

Ah, what would wrestling be with­out fake Russians and people waving flags and chant­ing USA?

So basi­cally Rusev has been work­ing his way through the lower card wrestlers squash­ing them in minutes. At least Big E actu­ally got some offense in against him. The match was a bit too short to amount to much, but it did seem as though if they were given more time these two might be able to put on some­thing pretty good.

If they actu­ally spend some time on this angle beyond Rusev… crush… they could get another PPV out of the match up.

Kofi Kingston vs. Bo Dallas

And we’re back to RAW mode again. This match was liter­ally announced at the last minute (on the pre-show) and had no build up what­so­ever. It existed for two reasons, to give Bo Dallas a chance to do some of his spiel and for Kane to come out and get some PPV time.

Kane is kind of in limbo right now wait­ing on Daniel Bryan’s in-ring return so I guess they felt it was impor­tant to remind people of his exis­tence. But really the segment was point­less.

Inter­con­ti­nen­tal Cham­pi­onship Match: Bad New Barrett vs. Rob Van Dam

Barrett is hot now and has been hot since he won the Inter­con­ti­nen­tal Cham­pi­onship. But they don’t really seem to be doing that much with him. I may be a bit biased on this one, because I was bored of RVD’s routine 10 years ago. So I’m not exactly invested in his matches. And well… his promos are kind of limited.

The match was fun though and RVD served the func­tion of seasoned veteran making Barrett look even stronger by compar­i­son.

tumblr_n6iqg6dgfu1rofocqo1_400Last Man Stand­ing Match: John Cena vs. Bray Wyatt

No real surprises how this one turned out. Cena has the Super­man nick­name for a reason. I did think for a while they were going for a differ­ent angle where Wyatt would get a disputed win because the referee had failed to count him out. I think I would have liked this one better, but I’m okay with the Cena win.

The match was so full of crazy moments and spots and Wyatt stood up to so much punish­ment that he comes out still look­ing strong. It’s time to end this feud and move Wyatt on to some­thing else though.

Diva’s Cham­pi­onship Match: Paige vs. Alicia Fox

I don’t think WWE are handling Paige’s title run very well. I think the idea is for her to have a clas­sic plucky face run where she gets pummelled by the heel wrestler but sticks it out to victory. The prob­lem is that for that to work you have to show that the face can wres­tle. Paige’s matches have been kept so short that essen­tially it looks more like she’s fluk­ing her way to victory each time. They need to give her a chance to actu­ally estab­lish her creden­tials.

On the plus side though the new char­ac­ter angle for Alicia Fox is great and I hope she isn’t shuf­fled off into obliv­ion now that she’s had her title shot.

20140601_EP_LIGHT_payback-nadine_shield-evolution_LNo Holds Barred Elim­i­na­tion Match: The Shield vs. Evolu­tion

A really messy match at the begin­ning because there were too many people in too many places so spots went unseen. But once it settled in this was another good outing from the feud that’s really been prop­ping up RAW and Smack­down for the last month. Over­all I think I preferred their previ­ous encounter, but there were some good moments here and the dive from the Titantron by Seth Rollins was spec­tac­u­lar.

Clever story­telling here too with Evolu­tion domi­nat­ing at one point but being so driven by a desire to punish that they let their chance at actu­ally wining slip by. I didn’t expect The Shield to get a clean sweep and elim­i­nate all of Evolu­tion like that.


So there were actu­ally some solid to great matches in that card. But there was a fair amount of very aver­age stuff too. One thing that would help enor­mously is a bit more focus on build­ing the feuds in the run up to the PPV. And since Money In The Bank is at the end of June… they need to get moving on that.

About Eoghann Irving

Overly opinionated owner and author of eoghann.com. You can get updated on his posts directly on the blog here or through the usual social networking suspects. What? You expected me to say something interesting here? That's what the blog posts are for. Eoghann has often wondered if people read these little bio things we have to fill out everywhere on the internet and, assuming they do, why?